Two solid servings of women’s life writing plus a novel about a Chinese woman stuck in roles she’s not sure she wants anymore.
Thunderstone: A true story of losing one home and discovering another by Nancy Campbell (2022)
Just before Covid hit, Campbell’s partner Anna had a partially disabling stroke. They had to adjust to lockdown and the rigours of Anna’s at-home care at once. It was complicated in that Campbell was already halfway out the door: after 10 years, their relationship had run its course and she knew it was time to go, but guilt lingered about abandoning Anna at her most vulnerable (“How dare I leave someone who needed me”). That is the backdrop to a quiet book largely formed of a diary spanning June to September 2021. Campbell recounts settling into a caravan by the canal and railway line in Oxford, getting plenty of help from friends and neighbours but also finding her own inner resources and enjoying her natural setting.
The title refers to a fossil that has been considered a talisman in various cultures, and she needed the good luck during a period that involved accidental carbon monoxide poisoning and surgery for an ovarian abnormality (but it didn’t protect her books, which were all destroyed in a leaking shipping container – the horror!). I most enjoyed the longer entries where she muses on “All the potential lives I moved on from” during 20 years in Oxford and elsewhere, which makes me think that I would have preferred a more traditional memoir by her. Covid narratives feel really dated now, unfortunately. (New (bargain) purchase from Hungerford Bookshop with birthday voucher)
Directions to Myself: A Memoir by Heidi Julavits (2023)
Julavits is a novelist and founding editor of The Believer. I loved her non-standard diary, The Folded Clock, back in 2017, so jumped at the chance to read her new memoir but then took more a year over reading it. The U.S. subtitle, “A Memoir of Four Years,” captures the focus: the change in her son from age five to age nine – from little boy to full-fledged individual. In later sections he sounds so like my American nephew with his Fortnite obsession and lawyerly levels of argumentation and self-justification. A famous author once told Julavits that writers should not have children because each one represents a book they will not write. This book is a rebuttal: something she could not have written without having had her son. Home is a New York City apartment near the Columbia University campus where she teaches – in fact, directly opposite a dorm at which rape allegations broke out – but more often the setting is their Maine vacations, where coastal navigation is a metaphor for traversing life.
Mostly the memoir takes readers through everyday conversations the author has with friends and family about situations of inequality or harassment. Through her words she tries to gently steer her son towards more open-minded ideas about gender roles. She also entrances him and his sleepover friends with a real-life horror story about being chased through the French countryside by a man in a car. The tenor of her musings appealed to me, but already the details are fading. I suspect this will mean much more to a parent.
With thanks to Bloomsbury for the free copy for review.
The Funeral Cryer by Wenyan Lu (2023)
The title character holds a traditional position in her Chinese village, performing mourning at ceremonies for the dead. It’s a steady source of income for her and her husband, but her career choice has stigma attached: “Now that I brought bad luck and I smelt of the dead, nobody would step into our house to play mah-jong or chat.” Exotic as the setup might seem at first, it underpins a familiar story of a woman caught in frustrating relationships and situations. A very readable but plain style to this McKitterick Prize winner.
With thanks to the Society of Authors for the free copy.
I’ll be checking out Thunderstone – especially interested in the author leaving the caring situation (I hear about this often – people wanting to leave and then something medical happens and they feel compelled to stay).
LikeLiked by 1 person
The medical themes were what made me try Campbell again, though they’re fairly slight overall.
LikeLike
I started The Funeral Cryer but didn’t make much headway with it. Surprised to hear it’s a prizewinner.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I loved Campbell’s two previous books but I couldn’t finish Thunderstone. The diary entry format didn’t work for me at all.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It took me a long time to read. I enjoyed it well enough but there wasn’t really a narrative, as the publisher tried to give it with the subtitle. I got the sense that she’s a nomad at heart and I doubt she stayed in the caravan long term.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I actually quite like the sound of the story behind Thunderstone, although it sounds like it doesn’t quite cohere, which is a shame. How frustrating that The Funeral Cryer doesn’t measure up.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I liked the setup and the medical elements, but the actual day-to-day was not so interesting.
I’m sure the narrator’s flat affect was deliberate.
LikeLiked by 1 person
[…] a brave act. Middle-aged woman makes bid for freedom but ultimately nothing changes: same plot as The Funeral Cryer and any number of other books, but this was so much better. How did Sagan manage such insight at […]
LikeLike
Has your summer of women’s lives become a little more onerous than expected? I enjoy memoirs, but would find so many of them difficult to navigate (but I know not all your choices are memoirs).
I loved The Folded Clock too. But I haven’t felt pulled to follow up. There are just so many good American women writing that sometimes reading one is where it ends (especially, ironically, when it’s such a good one).
LikeLiked by 1 person
Alas. Lots of my choices have been just okay, which meant I kept wondering if I should switch different stuff in. But now I’m running out of time.
LikeLike
[…] Why I have it: because of Beck’s review. […]
LikeLike