Short Fiction for September

I toyed with the wild idea of only reading short stories as my fiction for the month of September, but it was never really going to happen: I just don’t find short stories compelling enough, and in some ways they feel like hard work – every few pages, it seems, you have to adjust to a new scene and set of characters. In the end I made it through one anthology of flash fiction this month, and read parts of three other story collections. Mini reviews below…


Best Small Fictions 2017, edited by Amy Hempel

Now in its third year, the Best Small Fictions anthology collects the year’s best short stories under 1000 words. (I reviewed the two previous volumes for BookTrib and the Small Press Book Review.) Starting with a zinger of a first line is one strategy for making a short-short story stand out, and there are certainly some excellent opening sentences here. Symbols and similes are also crucial to conveying shorthand meaning. Two stand-outs are “States of Matter,” Tara Laskowski’s deliciously creepy story of revenge aided by a gravedigger; and Matthew Baker’s “The President’s Doubles,” in which an island nation becomes so protective of its imperiled leader that he ends up a prisoner. They’ve saved the best for last in this collection, though: the late Brian Doyle’s “My Devils,” in which an Irish-American boy learns how to interpret the adult world by deciphering what people say versus what they mean. It’s remarkable how concisely a coming of age and loss of blind faith are conveyed. Although there are fewer overall highlights than in the first volume, this is an excellent snapshot of contemporary super-short story writing, recommended for story lovers and newbies alike. (See my full review for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.) 


The Bus Driver Who Wanted to Be God and Other Stories by Etgar Keret

How can you not want to read a book with that title? Unfortunately, “The Story about a Bus Driver Who Wanted to Be God” is the first story and probably the best, so it’s all a slight downhill journey from there. That story stars a bus driver who’s weighing justice versus mercy in his response to one lovelorn passenger, and retribution is a recurring element in the remainder of the book. Most stories are just three to five pages long. Important characters include an angel who can’t fly, visitors from the mouth of Hell in Uzbekistan, and an Israeli ex-military type with the ironic surname of Goodman who’s hired to assassinate a Texas minister for $30,000. You can never predict what decisions people will make, Keret seems to be emphasizing, or how they’ll choose to justify themselves; “Everything in life is just luck.”

Aside from the title story, I particularly liked “Pipes,” in which the narrator makes himself a giant pipe through which to escape to Heaven, a place for misfits who’ve never found a way to be happy on Earth. Twisted biblical allusions like this are rife, including “Plague of the Firstborn.” A few stories have a folktale-like ambiance. It felt like there were too many first-person narrators, though, and too many repeating plots: “Good Intentions” takes up the same contract killing theme as “Goodman,” while both “Katzenstein” and “Jetlag” involve ejection from a plane. I read everything bar the 86-page novella Kneller’s Happy Campers; after so much flash fiction I wasn’t prepared to change pace so dramatically. So I’ve marked this as unfinished even though I read 110 pages in total. (Read in translation from the Hebrew.) 


Honeydew by Edith Pearlman

I don’t know what it is with me lately, but I seem to lack staying power with story collections. I read the first 40% of Pearlman’s most recent book on my Kindle and then just felt no need to continue. You could consider that a virtue of story collections: you can read as much or as little at a time as you want and pick and choose what bits interest you, in a way that you can’t with novels. Or you could say an author must be doing something wrong if a reader doesn’t long to keep turning the pages.

At any rate, I enjoyed Pearlman’s stories well enough. They all apparently take place in suburban Boston and many consider unlikely romances. My favorite was “Castle 4,” set in an old hospital. Zephyr, an anesthetist, falls in love with a cancer patient, while a Filipino widower who works as a security guard forms a tender relationship with the gift shop lady who sells his disabled daughter’s wood carvings. I also liked “Tenderfoot,” in which a pedicurist helps an art historian see that his heart is just as hard as his feet and that may be why he has an estranged wife. “Blessed Harry” amused me because the setup is a bogus e-mail requesting that a Latin teacher come speak at King’s College London (where I used to work). Two stories in a row (four in total, I’m told) center around Rennie’s antique shop – a little too Mitford quaint for me. 

Favorite lines: “Happiness lengthens time. Every day seemed as long as a novel. Every night a double feature. Every week a lifetime, a muted lifetime, a lifetime in which sadness, always wedged under her breast like a doorstop, lost some of its bite.” (from “Stone”)


Even though I didn’t finish either of these books, I’d gladly try something else by the authors. Can you recommend something to me?



Currently reading: After enjoying Bernard MacLaverty’s Midwinter Break so much, I picked up one of his short story collections (along with Keret’s) from Book-Cycle in Exeter earlier this month. So far I’ve read the first two stories in The Great Profundo, one about a struggling artist and a lonely widow who connect over an Emily Dickinson passage, and another about a cardinal whose father confesses he lost his faith years ago.

Upcoming: I have collections by Andrea Barrett, T.C. Boyle, Tessa Hadley and Alice Munro on the shelf. I also have far too many languishing on my Kindle, including For a Little While by Rick Bass, Whatever Happened to Interracial Love? by Kathleen Collins, We Come to Our Senses by Odie Lindsey, Music in Wartime by Rebecca Makkai and 99 Stories of God by Joy Williams. The ones I’m most likely to get to fairly soon, I think, are Difficult Women by Roxane Gay and The Garden Party by Katherine Mansfield.

Are you a short story fan? Read any good ones recently?

19 responses

  1. Not only is it a brilliant title but that jacket makes me want to pick it up and thumb through the book. I enjoyed Ship Fever which I read before becoming a short story convert because I’d enjoyed The Voyage of the Narwhal so much.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I do sometimes think short story collections are best just sampled at random rather than read straight through — but then you can’t count it on your ‘read’ list. Argh!

      I loved her book Archangel, which was linked short stories.


      1. I haven’t spotted that one. I shall investigate. Thanks!

        Liked by 1 person

      2. That’s an interesting approach though and could be one way for me to tackle the collections I have bought but never read.

        Liked by 1 person

  2. We actually have a couple of local bus drivers who seem to think they are god especially when it comes to deciding whether they will stop at a particular bus stop or not. Maybe they’ve read the story and been inspired !

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Ha ha! There are some definite grumps out there. By contrast, I found all the Dutch bus drivers and tram conductors very jolly.


  3. I’m not a massive short story fan, perhaps because I read quickly. I do love Elizabeth Taylor and Dorothy Whipple’s short stories, however.


    1. I’ve only ever read novels by Taylor (four of them now); I’d love to try her short stories. I don’t like long story collections as they feel like roadblocks.


      1. There’s a massive Collected Short Stories but it’s divided into the original volumes. If you like her novels, you’ll love her stories.

        Liked by 1 person

  4. Like you I find short stories quite an effort. I used to enjoy Katherine Mansfield. I wonder if I still would?


    1. I’ve never tried anything by her. This was a reissue of The Garden Party and Other Stories I found via NetGalley, I think.


  5. I tend to enjoy linked short story collections better than unlinked. I liked Olive Kitteridge pretty well, though I don’t think I’d feel the need to read a second time. While unlinked, Hilary Mantel’s collection was wonderful, something I plan to return to for help with my craft.


    1. Linked story collections are an interesting halfway house between stories and a novel as you get to engage with mostly the same characters all through. I have a copy of Olive Kitteridge but haven’t read it. The only book I’ve read by Alice Munro so far was Lives of Girls and Women, which was marketed as her only novel but is really more like linked short stories.


  6. Some short story collections I really like, you may have read some of these:
    Tenth of December – George Saunders
    Bloodchild and Other Stories – Octavis Butler
    Get in Trouble – Kelly Link
    We Live in Water – Jess Walter
    Not the End of the World – Kate Atkinson

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Ooh, I’d really like to try Saunders’ short stories after liking Lincoln in the Bardo, and I do mean to read something by Octavia Butler. I didn’t know Jess Walter or Kate Atkinson had written stories.

      Liked by 1 person

  7. More than ten years ago, a bookgroup I was in read The Collected Stories of Katherine Mansfield, which may have given me the idea to read through all of Alice Munro’s stories, which i did about five years ago, slowly, about a story each week. Now I’m reading through Mavis Gallant. Again, slowly. Given how much you liked Wind-Up Bird, have you thought of trying some of his stories? Maybe the key for you is to find author-first and then see if a favourite author can lead you into the form after you’ve fallen in love with their longer works? So Laila’s suggestions could be perfect along those lines (if you enjoyed any of their novels, I mean).


    1. Wow, just one story a week. Now that’s an interesting idea. It would have to be from a book I own in print, as I’d get too antsy keeping a library or Kindle book going for that long.

      I’ve sort of followed your advice with Bernard MacLaverty: I knew I liked him from reading Midwinter Break, so now I’ve been occasionally dipping into The Great Profundo collection and really enjoying it.

      I had the impression that Murakami’s stories were lesser works? I have two more of his novels that I picked up secondhand recently to read first, and then maybe I’ll think about delving further into the back catalogue.


  8. […] effort to read more short stories in the alliterative month of September; see also my 2016 and 2017 performances. (I actually finished Sarah Hall’s collection in late August, but I’m going to […]


  9. […] effort to read more short stories in the alliterative month of September. (See also my 2016, 2017 and 2018 performances.) Short story collections are often hit and miss for me, and based on a few […]


Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: