Seven Cats I Have Loved by Anat Levit (Translated by Yardenne Greenspan) for #NovNov22

“Most of the cats I come across must be able to sense right away that I am nothing but a cat in human clothes.”

This short memoir could have fit next week’s nonfiction focus, but because it is translated from the Hebrew I’ve chosen to use it to round off our literature in translation week. Poet Anat Levit didn’t start off as a cat lady, yet in the year following her divorce she adopted five kittens. The first, Shelly, was a present for her small daughters, Daphna and Shlomit, and then another four fluffballs tempted her at the pet store: Afro, Lady, Mocha and Jesse. Add on Cleo, a beautiful Siamese she bought on impulse from a neighbour, and Mishely, a local stray she started to look after, and there you have it: the seven cats who took over her life.

This is a loose narrative filled with little observations on the differences in her cats’ appetites, mannerisms, and relationships to each other and to the author. As much as she loves them, Levit seems to find the animals a heavy emotional burden: she constantly wonders if she’s doing her best for them, treating them all the same (better than her children?), and so on.

Unfortunately, I felt the most attention is paid to the cats’ various illnesses and vet visits, and especially the periods of decline leading to each one’s death. Pets only live a fraction as long as humans, so books about loving them often incorporate death, and some might argue that it’s an essential part of the story: that your care for an animal companion encompasses their whole life and includes the duty to ease their death. Fair enough. But it can be a downer to read about. So, cat lovers, think carefully about whether you can handle the content; if you’re after sweet anecdotes and antics, this is not that book. Something about either the writing or the translation meant that I found the tone either too matter-of-fact (recounting the physical facts of deterioration) or melodramatic, e.g.,

That evening, it dawned on me that I had to hurry up and release Cleo from the relics of existence that survived in his body. Sometimes, death dawdles for no reason. On the threshold of my cats’ demise, it prescribed the kind of suffering that seemed to have erased the sweetness of all their previous years at once.

– and not often finding a balance. Still, there are some sweet moments that pet owners will appreciate. (A similar read from last year: The Writer’s Cats by Muriel Barbery.)

[133 pages]

With thanks to Serpent’s Tail for the free copy for review.

19 responses

  1. MarinaSofia's avatar

    Definitely not for me at the moment, then…

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Rebecca Foster's avatar

      I know you’ve said goodbye to more than your fair share of elderly and unwell cats. Perhaps one day you’d find it a poignant read.

      Like

  2. alison41's avatar

    Not for me either.

    Like

    1. Rebecca Foster's avatar

      Understandable! (Lovely photo of you — is it new?)

      Like

  3. Cathy746books's avatar

    Translation can really make all the difference, can’t it?

    Like

    1. Rebecca Foster's avatar

      I tried to think if I’ve ever read anything translated from the Hebrew before. I think a couple of novels by David Grossman is the sum total.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. kaggsysbookishramblings's avatar

    Mmmmmm. Although animals have to leave us, I think I would like plenty of happy to balance out the sad…

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Rebecca Foster's avatar

      Indeed. A mention of the death to round out the picture, but perhaps not such a focus.

      Liked by 1 person

  5. margaret21's avatar

    I do like cats, but am far from obsessive. So not for me then

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Rebecca Foster's avatar

      I don’t imagine you’d pick up a whole book about cats, no 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Bee Shaw's avatar

        I was given this book as a present and read out of respect of gift giver…I love cats but this woman should be reported to the RSPCA…selfish and cruel…obviously has mental issues….!

        Like

  6. Simon T (StuckinaBook)'s avatar

    Oh thanks for the warning – I’d have raced towards this, but I can’t face reading about their illnesses and deaths. (Btw, if you are looking for something else translated from Hebrew, Etgar Keret’s stories are wonderful and odd.)

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Rebecca Foster's avatar

      I have a 14.5-year-old cat with kidney disease; though he’s doing very well for all that, I’d probably choose to avoid stories of cat decline in future.

      Come to think of it, I did read all the stories in Keret’s The Bus Driver Who Wanted To Be God, I just skipped the novella.

      Like

  7. whatmeread's avatar

    Kind of a strange subject, too. Not that I haven’t had cats I’ve loved as well.

    Like

    1. Rebecca Foster's avatar

      I’ve read a number of “cat memoirs” now and they really vary — they can be quite “twee” or sentimental. The best I’ve read were probably by Doreen Tovey.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. whatmeread's avatar

        It’s funny there are so many.

        Like

  8. johnwantling's avatar

    I tend to disagree with everyone else because I thought this book was brilliant. The death of the cats was very sad indeed, and brought tears to my eyes. I have loads of cat books and this book by Anat Levit is one of my favourites.

    Like

  9. […] my review of Seven Cats I Have Loved by Anat Levit, I complained that too much space was given to each pet’s physical decline. “On […]

    Like

Leave a reply to johnwantling Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.