#NovNov24 and #GermanLitMonth: Knulp by Hermann Hesse (1915)

My second contribution to German Literature Month (hosted by Lizzy Siddal) after A Simple Intervention by Yael Inokai. This was my first time reading the German-Swiss Nobel Prize winner Hermann Hesse (1877–1962). I had heard of his novels Siddhartha and Steppenwolf, of course, but didn’t know about any of his shorter works before I picked this up from the Little Free Library last month. Knulp is a novella in three stories that provide complementary angles on the title character, a carefree vagabond whose rambling years are coming to an end.

“Early Spring” has a first-person plural narrator, opening “Once, early in the nineties, our friend Knulp had to go to hospital for several weeks.” Upon his discharge he stays with an old friend, the tanner Rothfuss, and spends his time visiting other local tradespeople and casually courting a servant girl. Knulp is a troubadour, writing poems and songs. Without career, family, or home, he lives in childlike simplicity.

He had seldom been arrested and never convicted of theft or mendicancy, and he had highly respected friends everywhere. Consequently, he was indulged by the authorities very much, as a nice-looking cat is indulged in a household, and left free to carry on an untroubled, elegant, splendidly aristocratic and idle existence.

“My Recollections of Knulp” is narrated by a friend who joined him as a tramp for a few weeks one midsummer. It wasn’t all music and jollity; Knulp also pondered the essential loneliness of the human condition in view of mortality. “His conversation was often heavy with philosophy, but his songs had the lightness of children playing in their summer clothes.”

In “The End,” Knulp encounters another school friend, Dr. Machold, who insists on sheltering the wayfarer. They’re in their forties but Knulp seems much older because he is ill with tuberculosis. As winter draws in, he resists returning to the hospital, wanting to die as he lived, on his own terms. The book closes with an extraordinary passage in which Knulp converses with God – or his hallucination of such – expressing his regret that he never made more of his talents or had a family. ‘God’ speaks these beautiful words of reassurance:

Look, I wanted you the way you are and no different. You were a wanderer in my name and wherever you went you brought the settled folk a little homesickness for freedom. In my name, you did silly things and people scoffed at you; I myself was scoffed at in you and loved in you. You are my child and my brother and a part of me. There is nothing you have enjoyed and suffered that I have not enjoyed and suffered with you.

I struggle with episodic fiction but have a lot of time for the theme of spiritual questioning. The seasons advance across the stories so that Knulp’s course mirrors the year’s. Knulp could almost be a rehearsal for Stoner: a spare story of the life and death of an Everyman. That I didn’t appreciate it more I put down to the piecemeal nature of the narrative and an unpleasant conversation between Knulp and Machold about adolescent sexual experiences – as in the attempted gang rape scene in Cider with Rosie, it’s presented as boyish fun when part of what Knulp recalls is actually molestation by an older girl cousin. I might be willing to try something else by Hesse. Do give me recommendations! (Little Free Library)

Translated from the German by Ralph Manheim.

[125 pages]

 

Mini playlist:

  1. Ramblin’ Man” by Lemon Jelly
  2. I’ve Been Everywhere” by Johnny Cash
  3. Rambling Man” by Laura Marling
  4. Ballad of a Broken Man” by Duke Special
  5. Railroad Man” by Eels

 

I have also recently read a 2025 release that counts towards these challenges, The Café with No Name by Robert Seethaler (Europa Editions; translated by Katy Derbyshire; 192 pages). The protagonist, Robert Simon [Robert S., eh? Coincidence?], is not unlike Knulp, though less blithe, or the unassuming Bob Burgess from Elizabeth Strout’s novels (e.g., Tell Me Everything). Robert takes over the market café in Vienna and over the next decade or so his establishment becomes a haven for the troubled. The Second World War still looms large, and disasters large and small unfold. It’s all rather melancholy; I admired the chapters that turn the customers’ conversation into a swirling chorus. In my review, pending for Foreword Reviews, I call it “a valedictory meditation on the passage of time and the bonds that last.”

16 responses

  1. A Life in Books's avatar

    Seethaler is one of my favourite writers. He’s so good at capturing the richness of ordinary everyday lives. I thought the cafe setting suited his writing very well.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Rebecca Foster's avatar

      I loved the conversation/chorus scenes. I think The Field is the only one of his I have left to read.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Elle's avatar

    I love that conversation between Knulp and God.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Rebecca Foster's avatar

      It’s great, isn’t it?

      Like

  3. margaret21's avatar

    I’m quite a Seethaler fan, and as I haven’t read this, it’ll go on the list. But Hesse. To my shame he remains unread by me. Though your being ‘willing’ to try another by him isn’t exactly a glowing recommendation.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Rebecca Foster's avatar

      This Seethaler comes out on 25 February.

      I imagine I didn’t choose the best place to start with Hesse.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. Klausbernd's avatar

    Hesse’s style is simple and Neo-romantic. We only like Hesse’s novel “Glass Bead Game”.

    About forty years ago when I was teaching in Montreal there was a Hesse hype. I taught a five-term course about Hesse for post-graduates. That was number one on the hitlist of all courses.
    Nowadays I find Hesse quite often trivial in contrast to his therapist C.G. Jung.

    Klausbernd
    The Fab Four of Cley
    🙂 🙂 🙂 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Rebecca Foster's avatar

      How interesting to hear your perspective!

      Liked by 1 person

  5. kaggsysbookishramblings's avatar

    I really love Hesse’s writing, though I’ve not read this one for decades. I just read The Journey to the East and thoroughly enjoyed it – I think you might too. His longer books like Narziss and Goldmund, and The Glass Bead Game, are also excellent. Highly recommend him!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Rebecca Foster's avatar

      Thank you for the recommendation. Engagement with Buddhist spirituality (and at novella length) would certainly interest me!

      Liked by 1 person

  6. mallikabooks's avatar

    The Hesse is a new to me title and while I think the aspects you mentioned would put me off too, that dialogue with God intrigues me!
    The Cafe on the other hand is reminding me of two separate cafe centred books I’ve read, Cafe Shira translated from Hebrew and Cafe Unfiltered from France though both were in a contemporary setting.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Rebecca Foster's avatar

      Cafes are appealing settings for fiction since they bring so many disparate characters together.

      Liked by 1 person

  7. Marcie McCauley's avatar

    “I admired the chapters that turn the customers’ conversation into a swirling chorus.”

    This really appeals to me!

    If, in your second-hand travels, you come across the Granta issue that focuses on German writers (2023 I think), you might enjoy having a peek. So many of the pieces were interesting, not one by an author I’d previously read! At least I assume the Grantas are second-hand options there?

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Rebecca Foster's avatar

      I’ve not come across many Granta issues in secondhand bookshops, but they would be a possibility. I did find troves of Slightly Foxed in one and then in the LFL, after all.

      Like

  8. […] Nothing but Ghosts 1 We Would Have Told Each Other Everything 1 Hesse Beneath The Wheel 1 Knulp 1 Hilbig Eine Übertragung 1 Inokai A Simple Intervention 1 2 Jerusalem Red Alley House 1 Keilson […]

    Like

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.