I’ve now read all but one of the novels on the Booker Prize shortlist (is it any surprise that it’s the longest one, The Disappearers by Marlon James, that I’ve been too daunted to attempt?). Luke Kennard and Rebecca Perry are both poets, which tends to indicate that particular care will be taken over the prose. Apart from that and having unnamed first-person narrators, I see no similarities between the two books, which are wildly different in tone. I have a preference, and I bet it’s not what you expect. Both: Public library
Black Bag by Luke Kennard
This was uproarious entertainment from the meta first line onward: “If you met anyone as whiny, as disobliging and egocentric as the average narrator of a novel in real life you’d find them unbearable.” An out-of-work actor in his late thirties who survives from one murder mystery dinner theatre gig to the next sees an ad for an unusual job. All he has to do is sit silently at the back of a university lecture hall each week, wearing a black leather bag with eyeholes. The professor is repeating a famous psychology experiment about attitudes changing through repeated exposure. For the narrator, being black bag is about freedom from his identity and inhibitions; maybe, also, finding solidarity. For his friend Claudio, who streams footage of himself gaming for a living, it’s a potential investment opportunity. For Justine, a married academic the narrator meets on campus, it’s a chance for kinky anonymous sex. I laughed out loud at the narrator’s habits of imagining his life in a 19th-century Swedish village and voicing his parents’ dog’s thoughts, and at so many random lines:
Is it not the case that for most of my life I have felt like I have just put a large crisp in my mouth during what turns out to be a quiet and pivotal scene in a play?
In the kingdom of dumb f*cks the guy with the English major is king.
Think of the moment, following the 2008 subprime crisis, when cupcakes proliferated like a cancer.
Ridiculous the plot may be, but it’s as hilarious as the novel is at the sentence level. For all that, it is still a cogent critique of modern masculinity, hypercapitalism and artificial intelligence (the scene where he and Justine go to see an AI-produced film, The Orb of Homuncules, is side-splitting). My criticism would be, as I’ve heard from various others, that the novel is overlong and slightly aimless in the second half; it could easily lose the 80 pages covering Claudio’s temporary absence. Still, when’s the last time a Booker nominee was this much pure fun? ![]()
May We Feed the King by Rebecca Perry
An unnamed curator arrives at a historic palace to stage its rooms with scenes of historical accuracy, tenderly rendered in the sort of detail only the most attentive visitors will register. Among other things, she’s an aficionado of high-quality, lifelike (expensive) fake food. She throws herself into the work as a way of distracting herself from the emptiness of her personal life since her partner left. We figure this out by reading between the lines, because she’s quite cagey: “At this point, certain things had happened in my life. I was ready to immerse myself.” She also finds herself unexpectedly drawn to the archivist, referred to by they/them pronouns. Her sections are in one- to two-page fragments, titled in a way that can obfuscate or signal an interpretation, such as “Peeking through a Crack in the Curtain and Seeing Another Curtain.” My favourite passage came from “All Work Is Holy”:
The rule is this: it must appear as if the person or people have just left the room. The viewer must feel as if the air is alive with their energy, that they only just missed them, that they will be back in any moment. If this isn’t the case, the scene is no more than an arrangement of objects. The scene is dead.
Indeed, the French phrase for “still life” is nature morte or dead nature. To try to bring history back to life, Perry devotes all but the first 55 and last 26 pages to a recreation of an unwilling medieval king’s court. He’s only on the throne because his two brothers died. There are rumours of infidelity concerning both him and his wife, and talk of removing him for incompetence. Soon they will all pass from life into legend.
I loved the late scene when the curator is introducing the exhibit to visitors and hears their ideas about how we know what happened in history – this is like a transcript of absolutely the best uni lecture or event Q&A ever. What gets preserved and passed down, and why? To what extent is there meaning in physical artefacts? These questions are compelling, yet I only really engaged with the contemporary storyline, while the historical pastiche felt like sub-Hilary Mantel, occasionally evocative but often edging towards pretension. ![]()
I’d already read:
The End of Everything by M. John Harrison: A “dull, watery postapocalyptic slog [that] sheds no real light on the past, present, or future”. ![]()
The Things We Never Say by Elizabeth Strout: About “a likeable Everyman with the same …secrets and struggles we all have.” It’s “the most engaged Strout has been with the present day, and the most specific she’s gotten about political outrages.” ![]()
John of John by Douglas Stuart: One of my books of the year. “Cal seeks to reconcile his sexuality and artistic goals with his family’s expectations and his devout upbringing. The characters’ power plays and acts of desperation are heartrending, but mischief and love of colour and crafts lend lightness.” ![]()
Here’s my thinking…
Masculinity is a/the theme in four of this year’s shortlisted novels (from the Kennard: “men are mostly frightened and crazy and very easily misled”) – and in last year’s winner, Flesh by David Szalay, too.
I’ve felt sure that The Disappearers or John of John would win: previous winners whose works normalize homosexuality. I would want the latter to win for its beauty and emotional power, but I think the former more likely as the judges (including Raymond Antrobus, who is British Jamaican) may have an eye on the whiteness of recent winners.
Elizabeth Strout may be doomed to be a Booker bridesmaid. I don’t think this is her best book, but I wouldn’t mind if it won.
I would actually be delighted if the Prize went to the wildcard, Black Bag. But I can’t see that happening. The same goes for the Harrison (please oh please).
Let’s say, though, that the judges want something completely different. Then perhaps May We Feed the King is it. Mary Beard (chair) and Patricia Lockwood, in particular, came across as huge fans during the shortlist announcement event.
I’m torn, so I’ll just go with the novel I loved the most: John of John by Douglas Stuart.
What’s your prediction for the winner?
Dear Rebecca
We suppose ‘May We Feed the King‘ will make it (from everything we heard), although we would prefer ‘John of John‘.
The Fab Four of Cley
🙂 🙂 🙂 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
We are very much of the same mind!
LikeLiked by 1 person
[…] I think it was already on my list from a New York Times post. And lately, I saw a review of it by Bookish Beck and before that another by Cathy of 746 Books. A curator and […]
LikeLike
I bailed out very early on the John Harrison – it was all over the place and contrived.
Loved the Strout though I agree it’s not up there with Lucy Barton or Olive.
Not sure I’ll get to the Rebecca Perry before the announcement. Your description of it as part Hilary Mantel pastiche doesn’t fill me with joy
LikeLiked by 1 person
I really don’t understand why Harrison was shortlisted.
It often seems to be the case that authors win prizes for what I think to be their weaker books; I have to wonder if it’s a sort of ‘lifetime achievement’ award.
Whether it would strike you as poetic and profound or pretentious, I couldn’t say! You could always try an online sample?
LikeLike
Your review of Black Bag has convinced me! (and what a great cover)
LikeLiked by 1 person
It was a riot! The U.S. cover is a bit different but has a similarly comic strip representation of the central figure.
LikeLike
I agree with both these reviews. I don’t think Black Bag will take it, but I agree it was refreshing to see something so entertaining on the list. I didn’t like We Feed The King at all, but it seems to have momentum.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I do wonder if it will strike the judges as the ‘something different’ they’re looking for to distinguish their choice from other recent winners and nominees.
LikeLike
Very interesting Beck! I am currently reading Black Bag – that is the last one I have and I have then read them all. I think I have a week to finish it 🙂 – but my thoughts align a lot with yours. I enjoyed Strout, but standing it next to John of John and it is not close to the depth and execution. I have no idea why Harrison is on the list. I liked May We Feed the King. I think The Disappearers is an excellent novel, but I didn’t enjoy reading it. I like you am hoping for John of John!
LikeLiked by 1 person
That lines up with my expectations for The Disappearers — I’m sure it would be worthwhile, yet I don’t think I could put myself through the experience.
I’ve been really invested with the race this year and I’m so looking forward to finding out the winner!
LikeLike
Not long to go now!!
LikeLike
I really don’t know. As a retired teacher, I’d love to see their marking scale – then I could predict properly. All these big prizes are subjective and dependant on trends or feelings and other waffly things. Thanks for your thoughts, Rebecca.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I see what you mean. From my experience of prize judging, even where there is a rubric it’s quite vague because no set of guidelines can apply across the variety of submissions. Basically, they really are just looking for ‘the best’ (which is so subjective, and will change year to year because of who the judges are).
LikeLiked by 1 person
An out-of-work actor paid to sit at the back of a lecture hall every week in a black bag with eyeholes made me laugh. Is the psychology experiment the novel borrows a real one?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes, it’s based on a real 1960s experiment in Oregon.
LikeLike
I suspect I’ve been corresponding with an AI — any further comments from this name and website will be sent to Spam and deleted.
LikeLike
I loved Black Bag, but agree it was too long and meandering in the second half. It did make me laugh a lot though. (The narrator has a slightly similar tone to the TV series Baby Reindeer).
My personal favourite is Rebecca Perry, with Harrison next, then Strout. (I haven’t read Stuart or James).
LikeLiked by 2 people
I’m not familiar with telly, so that would have passed me by.
I wonder who the bookies’ favourite is? I wouldn’t be surprised by a Perry win.
LikeLike
I think I’d like both of these (I think the historical storyline in one of Ali Smith’s novels that we read together worked better for me, so maybe that would happen here too). Did you set out to read the list, or simply notice you were almost there, so decided to run for it? The one I most want to read is The Disappearers (I didn’t get far before it was due back) but I’ll look for John of John as well (there were just too many holds for that one).
LikeLiked by 1 person
I was awaiting the Perry from the library for ages before the Booker shortlisting; the Kennard I would have missed had it not advanced and a couple of blogger friends reviewed it.
LikeLike
I bought May We Feed the King and finished reading it in a day and I really liked it (4.5/5 for me). I think it helps that I love poetry and so I loved the style of the book. It’s the only book on the shortlist that I could get to though. Congratulations on finishing almost all of the shortlist!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m a big poetry reader but found Perry’s prose a bit try-hard.
LikeLike