Tag Archives: novella

November 18th: On the Calculation of Volume, I by Solvej Balle (#NovNov26 & #SciFiMonth)

This Danish novella, the start of a projected seven-volume series, was shortlisted for the International Booker Prize in 2025. I’m reviewing it today because the whole premise is that, Groundhog Day-like, Tara Selter keeps reliving the 18th of November. Book I covers her initial year of being trapped on this particular day. When she first wakes up and realizes the daily calendar page hadn’t advanced, she’s in Paris acquiring books for the antiquarian business she runs with her husband, Thomas, from their home in rural France. She also buys him a Roman sestertius coin from her dealer friends Philip and Marie as a surprise. Early clues that she’s stuck include repeated minor events such as someone dropping a piece of bread at the hotel breakfast and burning her hand on Philip and Marie’s heater.

The most interesting part of the world-building here is Tara’s discovery of how objects move through time. For the most part, what she acquires or consumes remains present or absent, respectively, despite the clock restarting. As the year advances, her burn fades to a scar and she is physically ageing, but Thomas is not. At first, she returns home and tries to enlist his help escaping this time loop, but when after 120+ days it becomes clear that their efforts are futile, she decides to leave him to the bliss of ignorance and hide in their spare room. It’s too heartbreaking to explain every morning why she’s here instead of in Paris. She keeps her own hoard of food to preserve his supplies, and goes out at night to watch the stars with a telescope. Each day, she makes a tally mark to count the November 18s she’s endured, and writes in this notebook.

That is why I began to write. Because I can hear him in the house. Because time has fallen apart. Because I found a pack of paper on the shelf. Because I’m trying to remember. Because the paper remembers. And there may be healing in sentences.

Of necessity – by nature and by design – this is a repetitive narrative. The subject matter is insular and the mood claustrophobic. It’s a fascinating thought experiment but for me it grew more tedious rather than more entrancing as it went on. There is a hint of interest to come in Book II: she goes back to Paris and has a new, dispiriting encounter with Philip and Marie. The blurb for the next volume at the back of my paperback indicates that Tara will try to achieve a sense of time by traveling across Europe and further into winter. I loved the idea of language being her means of survival, her way of recreating or even creating her reality. And I did feel for Tara’s predicament. But no way would I have the persistence (or is it an addiction?) required to read more about it. I have history of not getting on with (multi-part) translated phenomena: Elena Ferrante’s Neapolitan Quartet (I skimmed My Brilliant Friend – meh) and Karl Ove Knausgaard’s My Struggle (I read Volume 1 – pretty good!)…

Naomi F. and Simon are stans for the series. Book I was also recently reviewed by Kay.

 

On the Calculation of Volume, Book I by Solvej Balle (2020; 2024)

[Translated from Danish by Barbara Haveland]

(New from Waterstones with a birthday book token)

[179 pages]

#NovNov26 Buddy Read: Sympathy Tower Tokyo by Rie Qudan

Sympathy Tower Tokyo, translated from the Japanese, is Rie Qudan’s fourth novel and won the Akutagawa Prize. An architect in her late thirties named Sara Machina is chosen to design a skyscraper to house prisoners in comfort. The striking Sympathy Tower, which will sit alongside Zaha Hadid’s Olympic stadium in this speculative future city, represents a whole new approach to the penal system: these “Homo Miserabilis” are people who, due to social and familial factors, were set up for criminality rather than goodness and thus deserve radical empathy. Inside the tower, negative language is banned in favour of that which promotes happiness.

Narration is shared between Sara and her younger boyfriend Takt, and augmented by epistolary elements such as an excerpt from Homo Miserabilis by Masaki Seto, the book wherein the concept originated; and an article by American journalist Max Klein, who visits the tower in 2030 and alternates between envy and outrage at the concept behind it. Some of these texts are preceded by an AI prompt Takt uses to achieve a particular linguistic register, and Sara also engages in conversation with the chatbot “AI-built.” These scenes are playful – she accuses it of mansplaining, for instance – but ultimately fatuous. An opening Translator’s Note gives some context about another language-related theme in the book: the use of katakana (a phonetic alphabet that approximates, e.g., English phrases) vs. complex kanji characters. Sara voices the worry that katakana may be undermining classical Japanese.

{SOME SPOILERS IN THE FOLLOWING}

Normally I enjoy a narrative comprised of different formats, but here they amounted to scattered storytelling. There are intriguing plot points, such as Seto’s murder, the fact that Sara was raped as a girl, and Takt getting a job as a prison guard because his mother is an inmate there, but these aren’t fleshed out. Readers get little sense of Sara’s inner life; there are two brief mentions of the assault and a moment where she expresses regret over designing the tower, but I was frustrated at her withholding. I expected this to be a profound book about compassion, creativity and language (the allusion to the Tower of Babel is made explicit at the beginning). But because situations, relationships and mindsets aren’t fully explored, the novella feels incomplete even though it spans four years. I hoped for more about the power of words to deceive or to create utopias. While it’s an easy read and raises interesting questions – so is indeed a good book club / buddy read – it didn’t go deep enough for my liking.

Although my overall feelings were lukewarm, I must put in a good word for translator Jesse Kirkwood (who also translated one of my other novellas this month, Suspicion by Seichō Matsumoto), for deftly rendering the book’s humour and wordplay – which must have been a challenge given the general reader’s ignorance about Japanese writing systems.

 

We’d love to have you read this and weigh in!

Also reviewed by Annabel, Brona, Cathy and Emma so far.

 

Sympathy Tower Tokyo by Rie Qudan (2024; 2025)

[Translated by Jesse Kirkwood]

(Little Free Library)

[134 pages]

The Return of the Soldier by Rebecca West (#NovNov26)

To tie in with Remembrance Day / Veterans Day, I’m highlighting a lesser-known classic that my library recently acquired to supplement an “Echoes of War” display.

When this debut novella was published in 1918, Rebecca West (the pen name of Cicily Isabel Fairfield, 1892–1983) was just 24 yet already a seasoned journalist, and would go on to be known for her fiction, feminist activism, and travel writing.

The title soldier, Captain Chris Baldry, is being sent home from France with shellshock and amnesia. He doesn’t remember his life of comfort at Baldry Court, his wife Kitty, or Oliver, their little boy who died five years ago. The narrator, Chris’s cousin Jenny, is familiar to him – but his picture of her is from 15 years ago. The main consequence of his mind being stuck in a previous time is that he’s still enraptured with his teenage sweetheart, Margaret Allington (now Mrs Grey), whose family kept an inn on Monkey Island at Bray. When hospitalized in Boulogne, Chris sent word to her rather than to his own wife.

When Margaret comes to break the news, Kitty initially suspects fraud, while Jenny expresses knee-jerk prejudice against the lower classes: “I … hated her as the rich hate the poor, as insect things that will struggle out of the crannies which are their decent home, and introduce ugliness to the light of day.” Relief at Chris’s injuries not being physical or permanent soon gives way to grief at emotional rejection. Kitty and Jenny reluctantly agree to indulge Chris’s delusion until he can see a doctor, so introduce him to the household but allow him to spend all the time he wants with Margaret.

Disgust and gratitude trade off in Jenny’s depictions of Margaret. “She was not so much a person as an implication of dreary poverty, like an open door in a mean house that lets out the smell of cooking cabbage and the screams of children.” As painful as it is for her and Kitty to have to cede place to a stranger, Jenny is also aware that they owe Margaret a debt: “While her spell endured they could not send him back into the hell of war.” And as Jenny observes Margaret’s compassionate care, she sees the woman’s “personality … sounding through her squalor like a beautiful voice singing in a darkened room. … This wonderful kind woman held his body as safely as she held his soul.” Margaret’s selfless tenderness is in stark contrast with Kitty’s petty jealousy and Jenny’s obvious, futile desire for her cousin.

I’d not read West before, and while I’m not sure I’d pick up one of her long novels, I found her prose gorgeous, e.g., “There had fallen a twilight which was a wistfulness of the earth.” The last two pages, in particular, are heartbreaking. The plot turns on whether to leave Chris in happy ignorance or remind him of all that he has lost. He’s made a good trade: a soldier’s stoicism for a boy’s enthusiasm. When reality is the hell of war, who can blame him for making a psychic escape, and who could wish to disabuse him of his innocent fancies?

West plays up the irony of what recovery would look like in this case. She makes effective use of dichotomies and doubling throughout, and her small cast perfectly illustrates English society – with Jenny one of the ‘surplus women’ created by WWI. Somehow, war’s cruelty is all the clearer for its temporary absence here. I imagine this made an excellent stage play and film, too.

(Public library)

[140 pages]

Suspicion by Seichō Matsumoto (#NovNov26)

An ultra-rare foray into the crime section of the library for me, borrowed because I had filled a reservation for it and the length convinced me it was worth a try.

Journalist Moichi Akitani becomes fixated on the case of Kumako Onizuka, a former Tokyo escort suspected to have murdered her older husband, Fukutarō Shirakawa, to claim his 3-million-yen life insurance policy. When Shirakawa’s car drove straight into the water at a port, he was trapped and died, while Onizuka survived. Under questioning, she swore that her husband was driving, whereas the consensus seems to be that she was lying and drove him off the pier – but had planted a spanner (wrench) in the car so that she could break the windscreen and escape. With his newspaper articles, Akitani perhaps unwittingly helps to perpetuate sexist assumptions about Onizuka and condition readers to expect a conviction.

Over four years and several defence lawyers, the case gets drawn out so much that the initial furore dies down. But for Akitani, the fascination remains. There are two details that people get hung up on: the spanner, and Shirakawa’s right shoe, which was found in the car, quite beaten up. As public opinion begins to turn, Akitani is paralysed by the realization that if Onizuka goes free, she might have her gangster acquaintances come after him.

Although I found this somewhat dull until the revelations of the final chapter and the twist ending, it’s an interesting study of obsession, preconceptions and the femme fatale stereotype. Written in the 1980s, it has an atmosphere that hearkens back to the era of classic crime by the likes of Raymond Chandler and Dashiell Hammett. All in all, a pleasant entertainment that could easily be polished off in an afternoon.

Suspicion by Seichō Matsumoto (1982; 2025)

[Translated from Japanese by Jesse Kirkwood]

(Public library)

[98 pages]

Novellas in November (#NovNov26) Is Here!

Welcome to Novellas in November! The link-up is open (see my pinned post) and I’ll keep adding more link parties as needed. If you leave a pingback on any of my posts, I’ll add them to the link-up myself, if you haven’t already.

At the start of the month, we’re inviting you to tell us about any novellas you’ve read since last November. Cathy and I will both post “My Year in Novellas” round-ups tomorrow.

Don’t forget to get hold of the buddy read, Sympathy Tower Tokyo by Rie Qudan, to read and review sometime this month.

Keep in touch via Bluesky (@bookishbeck.bsky.social / @cathybrown746.bsky.social) and Instagram (@bookishbeck / @cathy_746books) and feel free to use the terrific feature images Cathy has made plus our new hashtag, #NovNov26.

The Parent Trap by Erich Kästner for #1949Club

Simon and Karen’s classics reading weeks are always a good excuse to pick up an older book or two. The mistake I sometimes make is to have just one option lined up; if I don’t get on with it, I can’t participate. I read the first 20 pages of Yukio Mishima’s Confessions of a Mask, which promised to be a psychologically astute picture of awakening to homosexuality in a repressive culture (“in this house it was tacitly required that I act like a boy. The reluctant masquerade had begun”) but also had the makings of a queer tragedy, which I couldn’t bear just now. Then I found a nearly new copy of The Parent Trap in the Little Free Library a few days ago and spotted that the twins share my birthday! Of course, I could have reviewed it for German Literature Month and Novellas in November, as I did with Kästner’s Emil and the Detectives last year, but instead I treated myself to the delightfully cosy, if far-fetched, story.

You likely know the story from a film adaptation starring Hayley Mills or Lindsay Lohan. I don’t think I’ve seen either, though they are culturally familiar to me. In Kästner’s original, separated twins are rejoined by chance at a summer camp in Bavaria. Luise Palfy has come here from Vienna, where she lives with her single father, a music director. One day an additional group of 20 little girls arrives from southern Germany, including Lottie Körner, who resides in Munich with her single mother, a journalist. It’s immediately evident that the two nine-year-olds are identical twins – same birthdate and -place – but with different hairstyles and their own personalities. They decide to switch places, partly as a trick to teach their parents a lesson, but partly to regain a long-lost and much-missed mother / father.

The girls have to be quick studies to cover up that ‘Lottie’ has ‘forgotten’ how to cook and that ‘Luise’ has suffered a horrendous decline in her handwriting and schoolwork. But there’s no fooling some, such as the doctor’s pug, Peperl, who is suspicious of a blonde stranger pretending to be an old friend. The girls are canny and stubborn, envisioning a new future and then doing whatever it takes to achieve it, but the emotional strain starts to show. I found myself upset with the parents’ Solomonic decision to split up their twins at their divorce. It’s just cruel; who would do such a thing?! In a sense, the whole premise of the novel is as hard to believe as the fantasy ending (“Catching up with lost happiness as if it were a missed lesson at school”), yet I gave myself over to it. Kästner’s tone is just right, shrewd and playful, and Walter Trier’s illustrations are charming. I recommend reading something middle grade every once in a while as an antidote to the awfulness of adulting and the occasionally depressing nature of modern literature. [Translated from German by Anthea Bell] (Little Free Library)

(The whole Pushkin Children’s classics range is brilliant – see also From the Mixed-Up Files of Mrs. Basil E. Frankweiler by E.L. Konigsberg and The Murderer’s Ape by Jakob Wegelius.)

 

Here are other famous 1949 titles that I’ve read (just 3 of the top 20 on the Goodreads list of the most popular books published that year):

I’ve previously participated in the 1920 Club, 1956 Club, 1936 Club, 1976 Club, 1954 Club, 1929 Club, 1940 Club, 1937 Club, 1970 Club, 1952 Club, 1925 Club, and 1961 Club.

Get Ready for Novellas in November! (#NovNov26)

Novellas: “all killer, no filler”

~Joe Hill

Hard to believe it’s nearly that time again. For the SEVENTH year in a row, Cathy of 746 Books and I are co-hosting Novellas in November as a month-long blogging and social media challenge celebrating the art of the short book (we include nonfiction, too). A novella technically contains 20,000 to 40,000 words, but to keep things simple we define it as any work under 200 pages.

This year’s buddy read is a 2024 novella translated from the Japanese last year:

Sympathy Tower Tokyo by Rie Qudan [translated by Jesse Kirkwood] is the author’s fourth novel and won the Akutagawa Prize. An architect named Sara Machina is assigned to design a city skyscraper meant to house criminals in comfort. While trying to navigate a middle way between compassion and recrimination – complicated by her own past victimhood – she converses with an AI chatbot. This engaging exploration of language, creativity and conformity comes with high praise from writers ranging from Helen Phillips to Bryan Washington. (134 pages)

Please join us in reading this any time between now and the end of November!

You might like to start off the month with a My Year in Novellas retrospective looking at any novellas you have read since last year’s NovNov and finish with a New to My TBR list based on what short books others have tempted you with.

It’s always a busy month in the blogging world with Nonfiction November, German Literature Month, Margaret Atwood Reading Month and SciFi Month. Why not search your shelves and/or local library for novellas that could count towards multiple challenges?

From 19 October a link-up post will be pinned at the top of my site so you can add your planning posts and book lists. Keep in touch via Bluesky (@bookishbeck.bsky.social / @cathybrown746.bsky.social) and Instagram (@bookishbeck / @cathy_746books) and feel free to use the terrific feature images Cathy has made plus our new hashtag, #NovNov26.

20 Books of Summer, 17–20: Jaouad, Kim, Merwin, Piñeiro (#WITMonth)

It’s time to draw a line under 20 Books of Summer so I can focus on hosting Short Story September. I’m technically not quite finished with these first two I’m technically not quite finished with these first two [70 pages to go in the Jaouad and 46 in the Kim], but I’ve read enough to form an opinion and will pop back later to add in final thoughts and ratings. My final four are a memoir of cancer in young adulthood; a page-turning courtroom drama about experimental autism treatment gone wrong; gorgeous nature poems; and a novella in translation that comments on disability, motherhood and mental health issues. Skip to the end for my one DNF of the challenge and a look back at some stats plus my most successful reads.

 

Between Two Kingdoms: What Almost Dying Taught Me about Living by Suleika Jaouad (2021)

{Updated on 7 September} Jaouad wrote a New York Times column about going through leukaemia treatment in her early twenties and what came next. After months of itching and fatigue, she fell properly ill while working her first postgraduate job in Paris and her blood test results were so bad that she flew home to New York. She would be in and out of hospital for the next five years, enduring multiple rounds of chemo and a bone marrow transplant from her brother. It’s a terrific granular account of the physical and emotional rigours of illness, as well as the strain it put on her relationships – being her primary caregiver was too much for her boyfriend, Will. But she also found a community of young cancer patients, many (like Max Ritvo) now dead. After 60% of the book’s length, as the title – its metaphor taken from Susan Sontag – suggests, the new challenge for Jaouad was resuming life. “I’ve spent the past fifteen hundred days working tirelessly toward a single goal—survival. And now that I’ve survived, I’m realizing I don’t know how to live.” She decides to undertake a cross-country road trip punctuated by visits to people who wrote to her through her column: fellow cancer survivors, a mother who lost a son to suicide, a man on death row in Texas. At first I thought this content felt tacked on and should have been a sequel, but ultimately it illustrates why she wouldn’t edit out her illness if she had it all to do again. I hadn’t heard of Jaouad before I stumbled on this book; from Instagram, I learned she’s now (at age 38) weathered cancer three times. (Little Free Library)

 

Miracle Creek by Angie Kim (2019)

{Updated on 7 September} After enjoying Happiness Falls so much, I wanted to go back to Kim’s debut, for which she won an Edgar Award. (There’s an autistic boy and discussion of therapies in that second book as well.) The bulk of the novel is set during the four days of an August 2009 trial. It’s been a year since a horrific accident at Pak Yoo’s “Miracle Submarine,” a rural Virginia hyperbaric oxygen chamber where regulars came for twice-daily treatment of autism, cerebral palsy, and infertility. Meanwhile, protesters gathered outside to draw attention to what they believed to be a dangerous and unproven technique, the equivalent of child abuse. Someone with Camel cigarettes and matches from a local 7-11 set a small fire under an oxygen tank; the resulting explosion killed two and seriously injured two more. The mother of one of the autistic boys was arrested for suspected arson and attempted murder, but as the trial goes on suspicion seems to shift to members of the Korean American family who ran the HBOT operation. There’s a lot to sink the teeth into here. Each character has secrets, and little revelations are emerging all the time, such that the prosecutor and defence lawyer are always having to adjust their approach. Like I’ve experienced with Kim before, this was intelligent, thought-provoking, and absorbing. It’s just the sort of crime-adjacent fiction I like. An author Q&A at the end reveals a couple of autobiographical inspirations: working in her immigrant parents’ convenience store near Baltimore as a teenager, and taking one of her sons, who had neurological deafness and chronic illnesses, for HBOT. (Gift from my wish list)

 

The Vixen by W.S. Merwin (1996)

it seems that the world is made of a single

summer as it always has been (from “Entry”)

I took this off the shelf because Merwin was one of the POV characters in The Daffodil Days, Helen Bain’s excellent novel about Sylvia Plath’s final years. I had no idea what to expect, and it took me a while to get used to his entirely unpunctuated verse. Only by reading aloud or in my head was I able to split the text blocks into meaning-rich phrases. The fox is a revenant flitting through many of these poems as they pinpoint natural rhythms and human traces across the seasons and centuries. A lot reference summer, in particular, so this was a perfect choice for the challenge. There are a few historical portraits but most of the pieces feel timeless, evoking a countryside locale where the speaker returns to find derelict dwellings given over to birds and trees. Mostly it feels like this could be England, but sometimes a dry aridity suggests the Mediterranean. There is a strong sense of temporality, especially of afterness – the close of a day, the tail end of a season, the still-resonant emptiness after life has left or activity has finished. But there is also the hint of an eternal present:

Seen from afterward the time appears to have been

all of a piece which of course it was but how seldom

it seemed that way when it was still happening (from “Completion”)

In a long book (~65 pieces), there were only a few poems that washed over me without making any impression. The run-on pace, alliteration, and close attention to the natural world made this utterly mesmerizing. I’ll be sure to read more by Merwin. (Secondhand – Bridport Old Books)

 

Elena Knows by Claudia Piñeiro (2007; 2021)

[Translated from Spanish by Frances Riddle]

Piñeiro is an Argentinian author known for infusing her detective novels with a political conscience. Elena Knows is a mystery of sorts, in which the title character devotes herself to investigating her daughter’s death (Rita was found hanging in the belfry of a church). But several elements make this atypical for crime fiction: Elena has Parkinson’s disease – “that f—ing whore illness,” she calls it; refuses to accept the police’s conclusion that Rita died by suicide – she would never have gone there in the rain, she insists; and drags her uncooperative body across Buenos Aires to confront an acquaintance she thinks might be able to shed some light. It’s a circadian narrative, divided into sections by Elena’s pill schedule, but expands its timeline through flashbacks to consider the complications of the mother–daughter relationship as Elena became more physically dependent. The eventual encounter with Isabel presents a contrast in the form of a woman who didn’t want to become a mother but had to because of a prohibition on abortion, which was only legalized in Argentina in 2020. While the approach and themes were appealing, I found this repetitive and the long blocks of dialogue in italics were challenging to read. This was shortlisted for the International Booker Prize, though I thought it had a better chance in that year’s Barbellion Prize race (returning this year!). (Gift from my wish list)

 

And a DNF:

Blonde by Joyce Carol Oates (2000)

Her problem wasn’t she was a dumb blonde, it was she wasn’t a blonde and she wasn’t dumb.

Sigh. Between February and July I read about 200 pages, then skimmed another 100 or so, then finally gave up. (My third Oates DNF. I don’t think she and I are meant to be, though I seem to have better luck with her short stories and own another couple of her books to try.) I engaged most with the early pages about her childhood with a vain, neglectful mother who ends up in a mental hospital; and then with her teenage marriage to Bucky Glazer and involvement in the war effort.

She was a sweet kid but so emotional. Wanting love all the time. She was immature and unreliable and I guess so was I; we were too young. If she’d been a better cook and not so emotional, it might’ve worked out.

Except that people were dying and being injured and the world filling up with smoldering rubble, Norma Jeane liked the War. The War was as steady and reliable as hunger or sleep. Always, the War was there.

In the part that I skimmed, she is starting to become known in Hollywood, with a nude photo shoot (for which she only earned $50), bit parts in films, and her famous stage name.

In the introductory Author’s Note, Oates writes, “for all its length, synecdoche is the principle of appropriation.” So, for instance, instead of multiple foster families, we just get one. Always, there was unwanted male attention, including molestation. I was surprised to find that the pick-and-choose, fact–fiction hybrid approach became a problem for me. I wanted to know if she really married a man named Bucky and wrote poetry. Yet I didn’t want to have to be verifying every fact either.

Oates’s kitchen-sink style involves imagined scenes and dialogue plus retrospective commentary and knowing asides; long, looping sentences and short ones; direct and indirect speech; lots of exclamation points. Lots of everything. The repetition will be deliberate, for effect, but I kept longing for a streamlined version that cut, say, three of every five sentences.

Anyway, this was certainly a project worth undertaking for Oates; you can see why it was irresistible to unearth the reality behind a legend. Norma Jeane is intriguing for her simultaneous childlike innocence and cultivated sensuality. (Secondhand – Awesomebooks.com)

 

20 Books Statistics:

14 fiction

4 nonfiction

2 poetry

 

7 by BIPOC

3 towards WIT Month (for which I reviewed 8 in total, with library reads and Foreword reviews)

3 rereads

I’ve learned this year that it’s important, momentum-wise, to build in a number of shorter books (6 of novella length + 2 poetry collections) and best to avoid doorstoppers. I was wise to pick some addictive, undemanding novels that tread the line between popular and literary fiction (Kim, Mantel, O’Farrell, Reid, Sullivan); anything that feels like hard work (Oates!) is definitely not a summer read.

I only read a risible 4 of the specific books I set out as options in my planning post, plus 1 of my additional ideas. (It’s ironic that I struggled to finish this set of 20 when I could have labelled anything from my shelves part of the challenge – in total, I read 39 of my own books this summer.)

My favourites of the 20 were Strange Weather in Tokyo, Prodigal Summer & The Vanishing Act of Esme Lennox (both rereads), and The Vixen. But What Belongs to You, Miracle Creek, Mitz, The Employees, Commencement, and Flush were also great reads. To be able to single out half of the books equals a huge success!

I also completed a 4-book diagonal on the Bingo card!

  • Summer in the title (PRODIGAL SUMMER)
  • A classic you’ve been meaning to (RE-)read (FLUSH)
  • Features a family holiday (MITZ)
  • Published in summer (ELENA KNOWS – July 2021)

20 Books of Summer, 8–9: Greenwell and Reid for Pride Month

As part of my Pride Month coverage (more coming up in Love Your Library on Monday), I’m reviewing a sophisticated gay novella that’s celebrating its 10th anniversary this year, and a gossipy pastiche of a Hollywood tell-all that I read for Wednesday’s upcoming book club. SPOILERS APPEAR IN BOTH, so if details of what happens bother you, you may want to skim or skip over some of what follows. In fact, it might be a spoiler just to include the Reid under this heading…

 

What Belongs to You by Garth Greenwell (2016)

Greenwell’s third novel, Small Rain, was my novel of 2024, so I wanted to go back to his debut and trace the development of his talent. This, too, is autofiction and shares a preoccupation with the profound uncertainty produced by illness and a newfound awareness of mortality. There are also, through flashbacks, glimpses of the author’s strict, religious Kentucky upbringing in both. But What Belongs to You mostly arose from the years Greenwell spent teaching English in Bulgaria. A version of the first section was published in 2011 as a standalone novella called Mitko. This is the name of the mercurial, possibly mentally ill and unhoused sex worker that the American teacher meets in the bathrooms of Sofia’s National Palace of Culture and keeps encountering—sometimes willingly, sometimes not—in the years to come. “Never before had I met anyone who combined such transparency … with such mystery,” the narrator marvels; he feels “held like his beloved, or his child; or held, I suppose it must be said, like his captive or his prey.” Their relationship is wildly imbalanced. The sex can be tender or violent. He gives Mitko money; Mitko gives him syphilis. The narrator meditates on his bodily fear, his sense of betrayal, the unknowability of others, and the deviousness of appropriating their stories for his art. I didn’t love reading about gay cruising, but the stream-of-consciousness section about his earlier life, prompted by news of his father’s imminent death, and the granular account of a train ride with his mother he spends observing a little boy and his grandmother were right up my street – masterful examples of how to translate experience directly into hypnotic prose. Greenwell is the James Baldwin of our time. (Secondhand – Awesomebooks.com)

 

The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo by Taylor Jenkins Reid (2017)

I always thought this came after Daisy Jones & the Six, but instead that 2019 novel brought renewed attention to her earlier work. They are both structured around biased first-person confessions in an interview setting, as well as, here, faux documents (gossip magazine articles). Evelyn Hugo grew up the daughter of Cuban immigrants in 1940s Hell’s Kitchen and escaped to Hollywood at age 15. That was through her first marriage; the others to come were for a mixture of reasons: short-lived passion, career advantage, public scandal, or masking the truth of another relationship. Because, in fact, the real love of this blonde bombshell’s life was a woman: fellow actress Celia St. James, with whom she co-starred in a Little Women adaptation. They have an intermittent relationship over the decades, both hiding in marriages to men so they can be together in secret and so that Evelyn can have the child she longs for. (Evelyn insists throughout that she is bisexual, which bothers lesbian Celia.)

It’s a rollicking tour through a convincing pastiche of an Old Hollywood career, divided into sections based on the husband of the time. Evelyn comes across as cut-throat: willing to lie and manipulate people to get ahead. And yet you can’t help but admire her shrewdness; she’s also sympathetic for the poverty and domestic violence she’s endured, if not for how she’s leveraged her sensuality (her large breasts were famously almost shown in a French film). Ever the actress, she is still performative even when she claims to be disclosing the truth publicly for the first time. I wondered if she was too clichéd as a brassy Latina.

My main problem, though, was with the framing story: Evelyn demands that Monique Grant, a biracial rookie journalist, write her life story. Evelyn is 79 and strangely sure she’ll die soon, so wants to both unburden herself and set the record straight. Monique is going through a divorce and learns from Evelyn to treat this simply as the breakdown of a marriage rather than as a personal failure. She also absorbs lessons of how to be assertive and advance her own career. But early on Reid signposts a shock connection to be revealed between Evelyn and Monique. That ‘big reveal’ was a bit of a letdown. It could have just been an interview transcript (hello, Daisy Jones!) or finished ‘biography’.

In any case, writing as two characters of colour took guts from Reid, and bisexual rep is always welcome. This was an undemanding, soap opera-esque summer read. The only category on which it might fall short in our book club ratings is the writing, which is lite (but good for guzzling). Think of it as a fruity cocktail in book form. (Secondhand – Community Furniture Project)

Reading Ireland Month, Part II: Dowd, Enright, Madden & Nugent

I’m catching up with a final set of reviews for #ReadingIrelandMonth26. I read two novels set at least partially during the Troubles, one of them for teenagers; a quiet novel about adultery and bereavement; and a thriller about consent and family legacy. I also read the first half of one more novel, a sombre one about the aftermath of a mental health crisis. Between this post and my first one, I covered 6.5 novels by Irish women, which I’ll call a win.

Bog Child by Siobhan Dowd (2008)

Fergus McCann is 18 and taking A levels; if he can only get three Bs, he’ll have his ticket out of Northern Ireland to study medicine at Aberdeen. This is no ordinary summer, though. He loves running on the hills at the border and here he makes a landmark discovery and embarks on a risky mission. The plot opens with Fergus and his uncle stumbling on the corpse of a girl while cutting peats. It’s a case for archaeologists rather than the police: the body is from the Iron Age and there’s evidence that the girl was sacrificed. An acquaintance then pressures Fergus into running parcels up and down the hill, right under the noses of the British at the checkpoint. He makes friends with Owain, a Welsh soldier, but gets a horrible feeling he’s partially responsible for the bombings he soon hears about on the radio. His family is enmeshed in the IRA anyway: his brother is among the hunger strikers in the local prison. There’s every chance that Joey could die before the summer is out, as much a victim of injustice as “Mel” (as Fergus names the girl from the bog, whose story he dreams).

This was Dowd’s third novel, published posthumously after her death from cancer, and won the Carnegie Medal. I’d say it’s one of the few best young adult novels I’ve ever read. (It’s shelved under Teenage Fiction at my library.) It’s an excellent peripheral glance at history ancient and modern – Fergus’s letter to Margaret Thatcher is brilliant – and effectively recreates a teen’s divided attention: friends, schooling, family drama, the future, and romance (via the daughter of the archaeologist). I searched my library catalogue for further books on bog bodies after reading Anna North’s Bog Queen and it really paid off! (Public library)

 

The Forgotten Waltz by Anne Enright (2011)

I’ve only read a handful of Enright novels and wanted to experience more, so picked this one because it was shortlisted for the Orange Prize. On the face of it, it’s a fairly straightforward adultery story, but the unshowy potency of Enright’s writing and her realistic insight into relationships set it apart. While married to Conor, Gina has an affair with Seán, who’s older and married to Aileen. Seán is part of their social circle but also someone she knows through work, and business trips are an easy excuse. “The office game was another game for us to play, after the suburban couples game, and before the game of hotel assignations and fabulous, illicit lust, and neither of us thought there might come a moment when all the games would stop. It was a lot of fun.” Gina narrates matter-of-factly, rejecting cause-and-effect language. She doesn’t defend herself, or fool herself that Seán is perfect. This new relationship involves as many challenges as her marriage, what with her mother’s death and Seán’s preteen daughter, Evie, who appears to be autistic and epileptic. The short chapters are all headed with song lyrics, mostly from love songs (“Will You Love Me Tomorrow,” “Stop! In the Name of Love”) whose ironic optimism underlines the novel’s gently melancholy tone. This reminded me most of Maggie O’Farrell’s early work, and more than justified delving into Enright’s back catalogue. (Secondhand – Awesomebooks.com)

 

{SPOILERS IN THE REST!!}

 

One by One in the Darkness by Deirdre Madden (1996)

Louise Kennedy’s Trespasses was our book club selection for March; I’d read it just two years ago, so skimmed back through and was impressed by its construction. Some were less convinced by the framing story and not emotionally engaged with Michael and Cushla’s affair, but we all appreciated it as a sideways look at Northern Irish history. One by One in the Darkness, which was also shortlisted for the Women’s (then Orange) Prize, is set close to its publication in the 1990s but returns to the Troubles through memories and flashbacks. Set over one week – Saturday to Friday – it’s the story of the three Quinn sisters. Cate is a journalist in London who flies home to Antrim to break the news that she’s pregnant out of wedlock. Helen is a lawyer and Sally a schoolteacher. They, their mother, and Uncle Brian have all gotten on with life as best they could, but their father’s murder is something they can’t forget and won’t ever get over. By saving that scene for the very last page of this novella, Madden keeps the horror of it fresh. Through one family’s story, she gives a sense of the scope of the country’s loss. But the book is not without a dark sense of humour, either. Madden was a new author for me. I found her work profound at the sentence level (see below for some favourite lines) rather than engaging at the plot level. (Secondhand – Awesomebooks.com)

“‘What’s wrong with Uncle Peter?’ ‘Two things,’ [Granny] said. ‘He thinks too much, and then he drinks too much.’”

“Once when [Cate] was home she’d remarked to Helen that she thought the forecasts were often inaccurate in Northern Ireland. ‘It’s probably deliberate,’ Helen had replied. ‘If they read out the average day’s news here and then said at the end of it, “Oh, and by the way, it’s going to bucket rain for the next twenty-four hours,” it might be more than people could take.’”

“Cate had remarked once that it was only when you lived away from Northern Ireland that you realised on returning how deeply divided a society it was, and how strange the effect of that could be.”

“There’d been well over three thousand people killed since the start of the Troubles, and every single one of them had parents or husbands and wives and children whose lives had been wrecked. It would be written about in the paper for two days, but as soon as the funeral was over it was as if that was the end, when it was really only the beginning.”

  

The Truth about Ruby Cooper by Liz Nugent (2026)

We read Nugent’s Strange Sally Diamond for book club a couple years ago and it was a great Northumberland holiday read for me, with a deliciously off-kilter narrator whose traumatized (and perhaps neurodivergent) perspective carried the novel. Here again Nugent prioritizes unreliable women’s voices and dark happenings, but Ruby is awfully hard to like. At age 16, she falsely accuses her older sister Erin’s boyfriend Milo of raping her. Milo maintains his innocence all along, but goes to jail for the crime; after all, DNA evidence can’t lie, right? Years of his life – and a heartbroken Erin’s – are stolen, his mother dies by suicide, Ruby becomes dependent on alcohol: all of this because of sisterly jealousy and an elaborate lie that their mother upholds rather than expose the family to further shame.

Narration alternates between Erin in Boston and Ruby, who’s moved back to Ireland with their mother. For Ruby’s confession to work, readers are kept in the dark about the truth of the incident, though only for 76 pages. Together the sisters give a tedious blow-by-blow of the intervening years – until Ruby’s daughter, Lucy, is raped by her boss on a drunken night out. Ruby refuses to believe her “because if it was true, that was karma coming to bit me on the ass.” This is where things finally get interesting, as Nugent explores ironies and familial patterns. But I’m sure I won’t be the only one to find the whole thing distasteful. Nugent clearly anticipates a backlash, stating in a prefatory letter, “I need to be very clear about the fact that girls and women like Ruby Cooper are extremely rare.” Was it worth undermining the #BelieveWomen campaign to explore a certain state of mind? Nah.

With thanks to Sandycove (Penguin) for the proof copy for review.

 

I’d also hoped to finish one more, but ran out of time. Here are my thoughts on the first half:

Show Me Where It Hurts by Claire Gleeson (2025)

Rachel knew Tom had recurring problems with depression, but had no idea he was on the verge of a breakdown when he deliberately drove their car off the road with the intention of killing his entire family. Their two young children die in the crash but they both survive – Tom held in a psychiatric hospital and Rachel resuming her life as a nurse. The chapters alternate between “After” and “Before,” giving relative date markers in weeks, months or years out from the incident. Gleeson’s understated prose makes it possible for readers to face a tragedy so awful we’d otherwise look away; it never tips over into mawkishness.